Main image
4th November
2009
written by admin

On the third day the delegation drove to the security fence/wall and then went through the Hawara checkpoint on the way to Nablus.  In Nablus the delegation had meetings with leaders from the PGFTU (Palestinian TUC) and Palestinian Authority representatives.   In the evening the delegation had dinner with the British Ambassador HE Tom Phillips at his residence in Tel Aviv.

The third day’s post is written by Mike Dixon, an USDAW National Executive member:

When I set off for Israel and Palestine, I wanted to find out what each side thought and find the truth.

After two days talking to various ministers and trade union officials I was excited and positive at what I had heard.  Today (Wednesday 4 November) we had meetings with Palestinians in Nablus: some positive things came out, but overall I was disappointed with a top official when this person called her neighbours the “enemy” and the meeting got a bit tasty shall we say.  I wonder if she should be in that job as she came across as very bitter.

Delegates walking through West Bank town of Nablus

Delegates walking through West Bank town of Nablus

There was a discussion about the boycott and it is clear that Palestinians don’t want it – all they want is equal pay and a living.

Meeting with Palestinian trade unionists

Meeting with Palestinian trade unionists

Over the last few years there has been a lot of good work done on both sides.  For example, there has been checkpoint closures, which in turn has brought more trust on both sides.

This means people will believe peace will come quicker.  Since the fence has gone up, suicide bombings have stopped – I think the quicker they get round the negotiation table the better it will be for everyone.

The Hawara Checkpoint into Nablus has been closed

The Hawara Checkpoint into Nablus has been closed

So back home we must spread the good word and work and hope that peace can come quickly.

I will say words do come cheap sometimes so we must take what we are told as true as we see.

5 Comments

  1. Woody
    05/11/2009

    With reference to the USDAW executive member complaining that the top official in Nablus called her neighbours ‘the enemy’- what else would you call people who occupy your land, kill your brothers and sisters, deny you your rights etc etc?

  2. Steven
    07/11/2009

    Get your history straight Woody.

  3. Woody
    12/11/2009

    So Steven what exactly is wrong with my history? The West Bank is not occupied by the Israelis? There are no illegal settlements? Israelis have not killed Palestinians? (Deir Yassin, Sabra and Shatilla, Gaza Invasion spring to mind)Israel has not curtailed any of the Palestinians rights – like free movement for instance? I think that maybe it is you that needs the history lesson.

  4. Yehudit
    14/11/2009

    I understand the Palestinian woman being angry and I probably would be in her shoes, although it doesnt help her win points with the foreign delegation, it is honest . But some history …

    The Falangist Christian militia killed the Palestinians at Sabra & Shatilla.

    I have visited Israel for extended periods and driven all over the country. The vast majority of the West Bank is not occupied, it is under the control of the Palestinian govt. The Israelis have a fence and checkpoints up, to keep out terrorists. But they dont walk around the territories with guns, in fact very few Israelis, military or not, go there at all. Any areas with soldiers are only where and when violence is expected to happen. Gaza has not been occupied since the Israelis pulled out their settlements in 2006, under Sharon. Same story with the fence and checkpoints.

    When real negotiations actually happen, there will be land-swaps, as advised under UN R 242, with the goal of making each country’s border smoother so no one has to drive out of their way to get to an area nearby, as well as making the borders defensible. At its narrowest point Israel is 15 miles wide. it takes 20 min to drive from one side to the other, even with traffic lights. I’ve done it.

    On the subject of occupying land… funny this conversation was in Nablus. For centuries Nablus was the Jewish town of Shechem, until the Jews were all ethnically cleansed. Same with Hebron and Jericho. Hebron was Jewish until 1929 when an Arab massacre plus indifference to it by the British rulers drove the Jews out. And of course the Babylonians, Romans, Muslims, and Christians occupied Israel and drove the Jews out numerous times.

  5. Nicolas
    17/11/2009

    Hello,
    Come On
    Nicolas